The Stain of Society: Why My Hero Academia’s Most Complex Villain Was Right (and Wrong)

In the world of comics, supervillains crave power, wealth, or world domination. For The Hero Killer: Stain, he kills not for personal gain, but to reclaim what he believes society has lost. In the modern era, Stain believed the soul of heroism had been lost in a sea of sponsorships, celebrity worship, and self-serving ambition. He concluded that the only way to restore true heroism was to eliminate all those who he saw as “false heroes”. When Stain appeared in Season 2, it was easy to dismiss him as a zealous one-arc villain whose motivations made no sense. But after rewatching the series following the release of the final season, I began to understand his ideology and how it changed the course of MHA’s story.

Let’s examine the Hero Killer’s philosophy and see why his “stain” on hero society is impossible to erase.

A Society of “Fakes”

A lineup of top Pro-Heroes from My Hero Academia, featuring All Might, Endeavor, Best Jeanist, Gang Orca, Mountain Lady, Tiger, Kamui Woods, and Edgeshot.

In My Hero Academia, 80% of the population is born with superpowers called “Quirks.” The birth of Quirks brought widespread panic as criminals used their newfound powers to spread chaos. However, ordinary civilians rose up and fought against the villains and restore peace and order to the world. This was the birth of “Heroes” and the Pro Hero System. But as decades passed and heroism evolved into an industry, the definition of the word “Hero” began to lose its meaning.

Today, heroism is no longer associated with the ideals of truth or justice. It is now a career saturated with sponsorships, media appearances, and a Hero Billboard Chart ranking heroes by popularity. Heroes have become celebrities and brands, more concerned with their image and paychecks than protecting the people. It was in this climate of celebrity worship and commercialized justice that Chizome Akaguro reached his breaking point.

The Evolution of a Zealot: From Student to Slayer

Flashback scene from My Hero Academia showing a shadowy, darkened silhouette of Chizome Akaguro (Stain) standing aggressively in a public park, surrounded by faded, white-out figures representing the public.

As a child, Chizome Akaguro idolized Japan’s #1 hero, All Might. He enrolled in a private hero high school with the hope of becoming a Hero just like him. However, he became disillusioned when he saw that his classmates were more interested in the status and wealth than saving others. Disgusted, Chizome dropped out during his first year and became a street activist to spread his message, The “Revival of Heroics”.

In his speech, he stated that current “heroes” were corrupt “fakes” who only cared about their public image and money. According to him, heroes must not seek compensation, and those who commit genuine acts of selfless heroism are worthy of the title “Hero”. Unfortunately, his message only fell on deaf ears. Chizome realized that if no one would listen, then he would have to purify the system by force.

Trial by Combat: The Hosu City Incident

After killing seventeen heroes and injuring twenty-three more, The Hero Killer: Stain became known as the executioner of Pro-Heroes. While hunting in Hosu City, Stain was confronted by Ingenium (Tensei Iida), the older brother of Class 1-A’s Tenya Iida. The two fought, but Ingenium lost and was left paralyzed from the waist down. Vowing to avenge his brother, Tenya inherited Ingenium’s name and costume. During his work study, he tracked down the Hero Killer in an alley in Hosu. Stain was about to slay the Pro Hero Native when Iida stepped in. Iida announced himself as the new Ingenium and declared he was there to take down Stain.

Strangely, Stain did not kill Iida for interfering. Instead, he lectures him on his selfishness. He told Iida to forget about himself and try saving others, warning him that acting out of pure self-interest and personal hatred makes you “the furthest thing from a hero”. However, Iida refused to acknowledge his own hypocrisy and stood his ground. Seeing that he was a lost cause, Stain tried to raise his blade to deliver the final blow. Fortunately, Deku saved Iida before he could be added to Stain’s body count. Iida yelled at Deku for interfering, claiming this fight was between him and Stain. Deku countered, saying that meddling when you don’t need to is the essence of being a true hero. Deku was not there to cosign on Iida’s revenge. He was there because people were in danger, and he wanted to help his friend. Moved by Deku’s conviction, Stain decided to spare him but remained determined to kill Native and Iida.

After being defeated by Deku, Todoroki, and Iida, Stain was finally arrested. Suddenly, a winged Nomu grabbed Deku and tried to fly away with him. Despite being injured, Stain managed to break free from his restraints. He ingested Nomu’s blood to activate his Quirk, Bloodcurdle, and killed the creature to save the hero who had defeated him. When Endeavor and Gran Torino arrived, Stain’s bloodlust radiated with such intensity that it left both Pro Heroes were frozen in fear. He roared one final chilling speech to the streets of Hosu:

“I’ll make this right. These streets must run with the blood of hypocrites. Hero…I will reclaim that word. Come on! Just try and stop me, you fakes! The only one man I’ll let kill me. He is a true hero. All Might is worthy!”

Then, The Hero Killer: Stain, the self-righteous slayer of pro-heroes who was defeated by three UA students, was finally brought down by a broken rib that punctured his lung.

The Clash of Convictions

A tense close-up of Shigaraki and Stain facing off in the dark, showcasing their conflicting villainous ideologies.

Before the showdown in Hosu, Kurogiri brought Stain to the League of Villains’ hideout in an attempt to recruit him. However, Stain was disgusted by Tomura Shigaraki’s lack of a goal as he only sought to destroy things that annoyed him, particularly All Might. He deemed Shigaraki the worst kind of criminal, one who wanted to cause bloodshed without conviction. For Stain, he shed blood to save the soul of heroism and to establish a new society filled with “true heroes”, while Shigaraki killed because he is an angry child who wants to watch the world burn.

After his arrest, a video about Stain and his manifesto went viral online. The footage painted him as a principled rebel fighting against a corrupt hero system. Stain’s conviction resonated deeply with the outcasts and disillusioned of hero society, such as Spinner and Himiko Toga, who were rejected because of their Quirks, ultimately fueling the birth of a new generation of villains.

A Legend Never Ends

Stain raising his hands up in a prayer to All Might for him to win against All For One.

In Season 7, All For One orchestrated a massive jailbreak from Tartarus. Stain was one of the escapees, but he did not join All For One’s side. He escaped with the prison’s security records to deliver them to the only hero he trusted: All Might. When Stain finally meets his idol in Kamino, he refused to believe that his idol, the former No. 1 Hero of Japan, is now an ordinary man. He questioned why All Might still called himself a “hero”. All Might conceded that his time as a hero had ended now that he was Quirkless, and the world had turned its back on heroes. Ironically, it was Stain, a villain, who reminded the greatest hero of the man he used to be.

He pointed to a woman cleaning All Might’s statue, which honored his last battle in Kamino as the “Symbol of Peace.” Stain informed him she was the last person All Might saved before losing his Quirk. Despite everyone else who had lost faith, she risked her life every day to clean his vandalized statue. Stain reminded him that it was not All Might’s power that made him a hero. It was his selfless dedication to throw himself headfirst into danger to help others with a smile that made him a true Hero. Through his actions, he lit embers in the hearts of everyone he inspired, from civilians to his students, and those embers continued to burn long after his own fire had faded.

In the final season, All For One and Armored All Might engage in one last clash. As they battled, Stain sniffed out the villain’s blood. He activated “Bloodcurdle” to paralyze the Demon Lord and cheered loudly for All Might to take him down once and for all. Unfortunately, AFO had anticipated Stain’s interference since he was the only villain from Tartarus who refused to join him. Using a combination of stolen quirks, AFO negated Bloodcurdle’s effects and mortally wounded Stain. AFO delivers a parting insult to Stain, thanking him for shaping the rise of Shigaraki and the League of Villains. Yet, even in the face of death, Stain remains unyielding. Bloodied and broken, he roared that the story of The Hero Killer does not end here. With his hands raised in a final prayer, he entrusts the future to his hero, All Might, before AFO silences him forever.

The Great Paradox of Stain: Was He Right or Wrong?


While Stain presents compelling arguments about the hero society, his ideology is riddled with contradictions that undermine the credibility of his crusade.

The Uraraka Paradox

A young Uraraka with her parents watching the crowd get excited when the heroes arrive.

According to Stain, a “true hero” must not seek rewards such as money or fame. But do his ideals apply to those who choose to become heroes to support themselves or their families?

Take Ochaco Uraraka, for example.

As a child, Ochaco Uraraka admired heroes and was fascinated by how happy people got when they saw them. Her family owned a construction company, but it had not received much business over the years. Wanting to help her parents, Uraraka decided to become a Pro Hero to earn money and enrolled at UA High. By Stain’s standards, Uraraka would be immediately dismissed as a “fake hero” because her motivation is rooted in financial gain. On the contrary, her desire to earn money is not driven by selfishness or greed, but by love and necessity. Her family’s financial struggles are beyond her control, and she is simply trying to use her Quirk to put food on the table.

After losing to Bakugo in the Sports Festival, Uraraka called her parents to apologize for not being scouted by a Pro Agency. She hoped that being scouted would have brought her one step closer to her dream of one day providing for her family. However, her father encouraged her to keep pushing forward despite her loss. All her parents wanted was for her to follow her dream of becoming a hero. Motivated by her family’s wishes, Uraraka continued to work hard to become a hero while keeping her promise to support them financially one day.

In her confrontation with Himiko Toga, Uraraka demostrates her growth as a hero. Before joining the League, Toga was rejected by her family because her Quirk, which caused her to develop an obsession with blood. Rather than treating Toga as another villain, Uraraka risked her life to give Toga the one thing she denied her entire life: acceptance. While she did not completely absolve Toga of her crimes, Uraraka acknowledged her pain and offered her a chance at redemption.

Uraraka’s story challenges Stain’s ideology, showing that heroism and personal motivation can coexist. A hero can pursue justice while also seeking personal gain, without sacrificing their values.

All Might-or-Nothing

All Might standing in a shining spotlight wearing his Golden Age suit.

Another fallacy in Stain’s philosophy is that he operates on a biased scale, with All Might serving as the standard for the entire hero profession. If a hero does not present the same level of morality as the No. 1 Hero, they are considered “unworthy” in his eyes. However, a society that is reliant on a single individual to uphold its values is doomed to collapse.

Before his death, Sir Nighteye foresaw a future without All Might and the world falling into chaos. As The Symbol of Peace, All Might was a beacon of hope that kept evil at bay and reassured people that there will always be a tomorrow. He was a once-in-a-generation hero—a man whose power, presence, and selflessness were so extraordinary that it was impossible to imagine another like him or a world without him.

According to Shigaraki, the public had become so dependent on All Might that they deluded themselves into believing heroes were perfect saviors who would always come to their rescue. As a result, those whose Quirks fell short of the people’s idealized image of a hero were cast aside by society and became villains. When All Might retired after Kamino, the pillar that once upheld society vanished. The criminal underworld, now radicalized by the word of Stain, began to exploit the vacuum left by All Might’s absence. They exposed the superficiality of the hero system and showed the world that its heroes were not the infallible saviors it believed them to be. After the Tartarus jailbreak and Dabi’s reveal, public faith in heroes collapsed and many Pro Heroes resigned, leaving the world defenseless against a new era of villainy.

The Purifier Who Poisons the Well

A close-up shot of Stain The Hero Killer.

The final fallacy in Stain’s ideology is his belief that violence is the solution to reforming society. Stain appointed himself as the sole judge, jury, and executioner, convinced that he alone could decide who was worthy of the title “hero”. But in doing so, he became a living paradox, preaching the values of true heroism while resorting to fear and murder to impose his ideology on others. In reality, Stain’s methods were counterproductive. He believed he was purifying society, but he was actually destroying the foundation of heroism he claimed to protect. With every hero he slew, he eroded the era of peace All Might established and the public’s trust in heroes, creating the conditions for AFO and the Paranormal Liberation Front to rise and seize control.

Also, let’s say hypothetically, he managed to succeed in achieving his goal, what was this new society supposed to look like? Was he going to be the overseer of all heroes, executing anyone who broke his rules? Could society even function with only a few heroes left standing after his purge?

True reform cannot be achieved through violence. Real change can only occur when the system is challenged from within through accountability, leadership, and collaboration. Without a coherent plan for creating a sustainable society, Stain’s vision is essentially nihilistic and self-defeating. In the end, Stain was not the cure but another symptom of the sickness he sought to eradicate.

Final Verdict


To a certain extent, Stain was right. The hero system had become a superficial commercialized industry where fame and fortune overshadowed the altruistic ideals of heroism. The commercialization of heroes created a hierarchy that incentivizes vanity over genuine public service that corrupts the very meaning of the word “hero.” However, his solution in trying to ‘purify’ society through murder was extreme and misguided. Instead of saving heroism, his blind conviction made him the architect of its destruction and accelerated the world’s downfall into chaos.


What are your thoughts on Stain and his philosophy? If you lived in the MHA universe, would you feel safer in a society of commercialized heroes, or in Stain’s world?

⚔️Share your thoughts in the comments!⚔️

Leave a Reply

Stay In The Loop!

Wanna see my latest post? Subscribe and receive newsletters in your inbox! Don't worry, I don't spam!

Similar Posts